SC rejects buyers’ late appeals against Lulu’s Manjeera Mall plan
The Supreme Court has dismissed appeals filed by three buyers of commercial units in Hyderabad’s Manjeera Mall against the resolution plan submitted by Lulu International Shopping Malls Pvt Ltd for Manjeera Retail Holdings Pvt Ltd. The court held that the appeals were filed a day beyond the statutory deadline and that the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) was wrong in entertaining them.
A bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva, in a November 16 judgment, said the NCLAT’s Chennai bench had wrongly invoked Section 4 of the Limitation Act, 1963, to extend the deadline for filing appeals under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). The provision allows a filing to be made on the next working day if the prescribed limitation period expires on a court holiday.
However, the bench said this provision could not be used to extend the 45-day outer limit prescribed under Section 61(2) of the IBC.
“Entertainment of the appeals by the NCLAT was illegal, as the appeals were filed beyond the time prescribed in Section 61(2) of the IBC,” the court said, setting aside two NCLAT orders and dismissing the buyers’ appeals as time-barred.
How the dispute began
The Hyderabad bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) admitted Manjeera Retail into the corporate insolvency resolution process on July 18, 2023.
Lulu emerged as the successful resolution applicant after its plan received 100% approval from the Committee of Creditors. The NCLT approved the plan on March 26, 2025. Lulu has since invested Rs 271.52 crore in implementing it.
Three buyers — Gorinka Pratyusha, Srinivas Kalluri and Rajani Kalluri — challenged the approval, claiming they had entered into agreements with the company to purchase commercial units in the proposed mall.
They alleged that the resolution professional, Birendra Kumar Agarwal, had wrongly classified the money they paid towards the full purchase price of their units as “advances from customers” instead of recognising them as financial creditors. They also alleged that the resolution professional had not complied with the NCLT’s directions to include their claims in the Information Memorandum.
Why the appeals were late
Under Section 61(2) of the IBC, an appeal against an NCLT order must be filed within 30 days. The NCLAT can condone a delay of up to another 15 days, but the law does not allow any further extension.
In this case, the 30-day period ended on April 25, 2025, while the absolute deadline of 45 days fell on May 10, a second Saturday. The buyers filed their appeals on May 11, the 46th day.
The NCLAT condoned the delay on October 10, 2025, reasoning that May 10 was a court holiday and that Section 4 of the Limitation Act allowed the appeals to be filed on the next day.
Lulu challenged this decision, relying on the Supreme Court’s judgment in Tata Steel Ltd vs Raj Kumar Banerjee. In that case, the court had clarified that the holiday provision under Section 4 applies to the prescribed limitation period and cannot be used to extend the additional time available for condonation at the discretion of a court or tribunal.
The NCLAT subsequently condoned a three-day delay by Lulu in filing its applications seeking recall of the October 10 order. However, on February 10, 2026, it rejected the applications, saying its earlier decision had been taken on merits and that a subsequent legal precedent could not be a ground for recalling it.
Supreme Court pulls up NCLAT
The Supreme Court said the NCLAT had got its facts wrong. The Tata Steel judgment was delivered on May 7, 2025, well before the tribunal passed its order on October 10 that year.
The bench also made it clear that once the Supreme Court interprets a statutory provision, that interpretation becomes the law of the land. An earlier order contrary to that interpretation cannot be allowed to stand merely because it was passed before the issue was brought to the tribunal’s notice, unless the order has attained finality.
The court acknowledged that the NCLAT does not have the power to review its orders under the IBC. However, it pointed out that the tribunal does have the inherent power to recall an order under Rule 11 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016.
This power was recognised by a five-member NCLAT bench in Union Bank of India vs Dinkar T Venkatasubramanian and subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court in Union Bank of India vs Financial Creditors of Amtek Auto Ltd.
The bench said the NCLAT was therefore not justified in refusing to exercise its recall powers despite being made aware of the settled legal position.
It also noted that the buyers had failed to establish sufficient grounds for the delay. Their appeals were e-filed on May 11, which was a Sunday and a holiday. The court said they could have just as easily filed them electronically on May 10.
Rejecting the buyers’ argument that the NCLAT’s October 10 order had attained finality because it was not separately challenged, the Supreme Court termed it a “specious argument”. It said Lulu’s recall applications had kept the issue alive and that the court could correct the error while exercising its appellate jurisdiction under Section 62 of the IBC.
The Supreme Court had stayed the NCLAT proceedings on March 16, 2026. With its November 16 ruling, it allowed Lulu’s recall applications, set aside the NCLAT’s October 10, 2025 order and dismissed the buyers’ appeals (Company Appeals (AT)(CH)(Ins) Nos. 388 and 389 of 2025) as time-barred. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.
Discover more from Insolvency Tracker
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.