Seven years on, personal guarantor insolvency yields lenders barely 1% of claims
Seven years after the insolvency law was extended to promoters who personally guarantee corporate loans, lenders have recovered only Rs 234.56 crore — about 1 per cent of their admitted claims — from the handful of cases that have reached a settled outcome, latest data from the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) show.
According to the IBBI’s quarterly newsletter for July–September 2026, 5,329 applications had been filed for personal insolvency resolution of personal guarantors (PGs) to corporate debtors as of September 30, 2026. Of these, just 64 have ended with an approved repayment plan. In those 64 cases, creditors have realised Rs 234.56 crore, which the regulator itself pegs at “around 1%” of admitted claims.
The contrast with corporate insolvency is stark. Creditors of companies resolved under the Code have taken a haircut of about 69 per cent on admitted claims — in other words, they recovered roughly 31 per cent — the same newsletter shows.
Who is filing, and where cases are stuck
The provisions on insolvency and bankruptcy of PGs came into force on December 1, 2019. Since then, creditors have driven most of the action: 4,312 applications were filed by creditors under Section 95, against 1,017 filed by guarantors themselves under Section 94. Almost all — 5,278 — are before benches of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT); 51 are before Debt Recovery Tribunals.
Resolution professionals (RPs) have been appointed in only 2,244 cases, or about 42 per cent of applications filed. Bankruptcy applications — the next step when a repayment plan fails or is not submitted — have been filed against 349 guarantors as of September 2026.
Filings peaked in 2024-25 and have dropped sharply since:
| Period | By debtors (s.94) | By creditors (s.95) | Total | RPs appointed |
| 2019-20 | 4 | 23 | 27 | 2 |
| 2020-21 | 27 | 255 | 282 | 35 |
| 2021-22 | 88 | 961 | 1,049 | 469 |
| 2022-23 | 88 | 909 | 997 | 557 |
| 2023-24 | 250 | 587 | 837 | 595 |
| 2024-25 | 173 | 892 | 1,065 | 232 |
| 2025-26 | 284 | 482 | 766 | 179 |
| Apr–Jun 2026 | 67 | 121 | 188 | 78 |
| Jul–Sep 2026 | 36 | 82 | 118 | 97 |
| Total | 1,017 | 4,312 | 5,329 | 2,244 |
Source: IBBI Insolvency and Bankruptcy News, July–September 2026 (Table 17). Data provisional.
The fall in self-filed applications in the September quarter — 36, down from 284 in all of 2025-26 — coincides with a change in law that removed the main incentive for guarantors to file against themselves.
The moratorium loophole, and how it was shut
Until this year, the mere filing of a personal insolvency application triggered an interim moratorium under Section 96 (and Section 124 for bankruptcy), halting recovery action against the guarantor. Courts found the provision was being abused. Hearing writ petitions by banks in Indian Bank vs Shabbir Abbas Patel & Ors, the Bombay High Court observed that applications were frequently being filed by chronic defaulters, often collusively, solely to stall lawful recovery, according to the IBBI’s summary of the ruling.
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026, which came into force on May 26, 2026, inserted sub-section (4) in Section 96 to curb this. The question then was whether the change applied to thousands of applications already pending.
The Bombay High Court in Tata Capital Financial Services vs Neel Motors LLP (July 24, 2026) and the Delhi High Court in IDBI Trusteeship Services vs Manish Jain (August 19, 2026) held that it did. In the Shabbir Abbas Patel matter, a division bench of the Bombay High Court held the amendment to be remedial and retroactive, and allowed lenders’ writ petitions against DRT orders that had restrained recovery under the SARFAESI Act.
The IBBI followed with a circular on September 21, 2026, clarifying that the interim moratorium for PGs ceased to operate from May 26, 2026, in all applications pending on that date. A separate IBBI discussion paper of July 2 proposes that applicants be required to inform the other party in writing, within 30 days, that the moratorium no longer applies.
A second change also strengthens lenders’ hands. Regulation 28A of the CIRP Regulations, effective June 1, 2026, allows a guarantor’s secured assets to be included in the resolution of the company itself. In one case cited by the IBBI, involving GV Annai Hospital LLP, the NCLT allowed the corporate process to continue for 90 more days after the promoter directors, who had mortgaged land to Karur Vysya Bank as personal guarantee, agreed to include the land.
The big names
Subhash Chandra (Essel/Zee group): The most closely watched case shows why recoveries are so thin. In Indiabulls Housing Finance vs Dr Subhash Chandra, the RP sought approval of a repayment plan offering Rs 6.5 crore against admitted claims of about Rs 21,697 crore, as per the IBBI newsletter. Major lenders including IndusInd Bank, Canara Bank and HDFC Bank opposed the plan, calling the recovery rate negligible, and alleged that the 80.814 per cent vote approving it was pushed through by related parties.
The original NCLT bench split: the judicial member approved the plan on a literal reading of “associate” under Section 79(2)(g) and the limited role of the tribunal under Section 114, while the technical member favoured rejection, citing the exclusion of alleged associates and the absence of a forensic audit to trace the guarantor’s assets. The third member, Nilesh Sharma, in an order pronounced on August 25, 2026, held that the challenged entities’ votes were valid. The original bench then said no majority had emerged, and a five-member bench constituted by the NCLT President stayed the third member’s order on September 1, 2026. The matter is pending, the IBBI said.
The case began with a Rs 170-crore loan by Indiabulls Housing Finance (now Sammaan Capital) to group firm Vivek Infracon in 2016, which Chandra had guaranteed.
Venugopal Dhoot (Videocon): The NCLT’s Mumbai bench admitted SBI’s personal insolvency petition against the former Videocon promoter on April 8, 2026. Dhoot offered Rs 600 crore over 36 months, linked to a proposed real estate project in Siliguri — reportedly 0.42 per cent of admitted dues. After the NCLT rejected the plan in July, a bench of Vinay Goel and Charanjeet Singh Gulati declared him bankrupt on November 5, 2026, over dues of Rs 12,668 crore, and appointed a bankruptcy trustee to administer his estate.
Anil Ambani (Reliance Group): On June 11, 2026, the NCLT Mumbai admitted SBI’s 2020 application against Ambani as guarantor for loans to Reliance Communications and Reliance Infratel, over an alleged default of Rs 853.25 crore. The tribunal rejected his argument that the guarantee was discharged by RCom’s resolution plan, and appointed Prashant Jain as RP. Ambani, who calls the guarantee disputed, has appealed to the NCLAT.
Regulator moves to plug gaps
The Chandra case appears to have shaped the IBBI’s latest proposals. A discussion paper issued on September 12, 2026, seeks to bring safeguards similar to those in corporate insolvency into PG cases. Creditors who are related parties of the guarantor would get a nil voting share. RPs would have to examine whether the guarantor was party to preferential, undervalued, fraudulent or extortionate transactions under Sections 164, 164A, 165 and 167, and a registered valuer would determine the fair and realisable value of the guarantor’s assets.
Creditors would also have to record the reasons for their decision. Where the proposed repayment is significantly lower than admitted claims or the realisable value of assets, they would have to explain why the plan is better than bankruptcy. Public comments closed on October 3, 2026.
Separately, the IBBI has again extended the deadline for RPs to file PGIRP monitoring forms, to December 31, 2026 — a sign that the regulator’s own data on these cases is still being built up.
Discover more from Insolvency Tracker
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.