SC sinks Twinstar’s Videocon plan, hands process back to lenders; Dhoot loses fight over overseas oil assets
The Supreme Court on Monday upheld the NCLAT’s decision to set aside Twinstar Technologies’ ₹2,962.02-crore resolution plan for Videocon Industries Ltd (VIL) and 12 group companies. The resolution process returns to the committee of creditors (CoC), nearly five and a half years after the NCLT first approved the plan and more than eight years after the first group company was admitted into insolvency.
A bench of Justices P.S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe dismissed all eight sets of appeals in the batch. Three were filed by Twinstar, a Vedanta group company. Four were filed by former promoter Venugopal Dhoot, and one by the VIL Vendors Association. The judgment was authored by Justice Aradhe.
The court ruled on three fronts. First, it held that a plan paying dissenting financial creditors through long-dated non-convertible debentures (NCDs) breaches the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). Second, it held that a CoC can revisit its approval once that approval is set aside on appeal. Third, it held that the group’s oil and gas interests in Brazil and Indonesia, held through subsidiaries, cannot be pulled into VIL’s insolvency estate. It also laid down five conditions to govern when the NCLAT can send an approved plan back to lenders.
How the case reached the court
State Bank of India (SBI) and other lenders moved Section 7 applications against 13 Videocon group companies. The NCLT admitted them between June and September 2018 and consolidated the processes in August 2019.
The resolution professional received 11 plans; two were found compliant. Registered valuers put the group’s fair value at ₹4,069.95 crore and its liquidation value at ₹2,568.13 crore.
Twinstar’s amended plan of November 2020 offered:
- ₹200 crore upfront to financial creditors
- NCDs with a face value of ₹2,700 crore at a 6.65% annual coupon, redeemable in five instalments: ₹200 crore 25 months after closing, then four of ₹625 crore each in years three to six
- 8% equity in VIL and the companies’ cash balances to financial creditors
- ₹52 crore to workmen and employees, and ₹10 crore to operational creditors
The CoC approved the plan on December 11, 2020, with 95.09% of the vote. Four lenders dissented: Bank of Maharashtra (1.97%), IFCI (1.03%), SIDBI (0.053%) and ABG Shipyard (0.024%). Dhoot’s Section 12A proposal to withdraw the process was rejected by 98.14%.
On June 8, 2021, the NCLT approved the plan. It noted that against admitted claims of ₹64,838.63 crore, the plan implied a 95.85% haircut, with operational creditors getting 0.72%. It directed that the dissenting lenders be paid their liquidation value in cash, upfront, ahead of the assenting lenders.
The NCLAT stayed that approval in July 2021. In September 2021, the CoC, through SBI on behalf of about 94.98% of the vote, told the tribunal it wished to reconsider the plan “in the larger public interest”. On January 5, 2022, the NCLAT set aside the approval and sent the matter back to the CoC. The CoC then voted 97% to invite fresh bids, but the Supreme Court froze the process in February 2022.
Twinstar’s appeals: the six questions
The court framed six questions in Twinstar’s appeals. It ruled against the company on five and for it on one, but that one did not change the outcome.
1. What tribunals can do with a plan
The court said the NCLT and NCLAT are “adjudicatory bodies and not merely approving authorities”. Following K. Sashidhar and Essar Steel, it held that they cannot interfere with the CoC’s commercial decisions on merits, and cannot rewrite or modify a plan. The NCLT’s job is to check that a plan meets Section 30(2) of the IBC. The NCLAT can interfere only on the five grounds listed in Section 61(3).
2. NCLAT can send a plan back to the CoC
The court held that the power to remit a plan to the CoC is implied in the NCLAT’s appellate power. It called remand “not only permissible but… the only lawful course” for a defective plan. Tribunals cannot modify plans, it said, and rejecting a plan outright under Section 31(2) can push a company into liquidation, which the IBC treats as a last resort. It also cited Rule 11 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016, which preserves the tribunal’s inherent powers.
Twinstar argued, in the alternative, that its existing plan alone should be sent back for reconsideration, relying on the Jaiprakash Associates order. The court refused. Once a plan’s approval is set aside, it said, the CoC must exercise its commercial wisdom afresh, including deciding whether to look at a modified plan or invite new bids. Confining the CoC to Twinstar’s plan “would itself be an intrusion” into that domain. The Jaiprakash order was passed under Article 142 and was expressly not to be treated as a precedent.
The court noted that the IBC (Amendment) Act, 2026, added a proviso to Section 31(2). It lets the NCLT give the CoC notice to fix defects before rejecting a plan. The court’s ruling rests on the law as it stood earlier, but it said the amendment “confirms the legislative policy” that defective plans go back to the CoC.
3. Debentures are not ‘payment’ to dissenters
The central finding is that the plan violated Section 30(2)(b) of the IBC and Regulation 38(1)(b) of the CIRP Regulations.
The dissenting lenders were not carved out of the NCD structure. Their entitlement was to be worked out within the same instruments, with a priority that, according to Bank of Maharashtra, amounted to redemption “a day before” the assenting lenders. Applying the three-judge bench ruling in Jaypee Kensington, the court held that “payment” to a dissenting financial creditor means payment in money. A lender who chooses to exit cannot be forced to stay attached to the company through equity or securities.
“A plan which leaves the dissenting financial creditors to be discharged, in substance, through debentures redeemable over a period of six years does not provide for ‘payment’,” the court said.
Twinstar relied on Clause 3.5.7 of its plan, which promised that dissenters would “in all circumstances and in any event” be paid strictly as per Section 30(2)(b). The court rejected this. “Compliance with Section 30(2) of the Code is to be found in the terms of the plan, and not in an undertaking to comply,” it said. The plan also failed to give dissenters priority over assenting lenders, as Regulation 38(1)(b) requires.
4. The NCLT could not fix the plan itself
The NCLT tried to cure the defect by ordering that dissenters be paid liquidation value in cash, upfront. It did so after the CoC’s counsel stated that dissenters would be paid upfront. The court held that this was “in substance modification of the resolution plan”, which is impermissible. The ₹200 crore upfront cash was meant for financial creditors as a class, so the direction changed both the plan’s payment structure and the order of disbursement among lenders. Only the CoC can alter a plan, by the 66% vote required under Section 30(4).
5. CCI approval: Twinstar wins this point
The NCLAT had held that the prior approval of the Competition Commission of India (CCI), required by the proviso to Section 31(4), was not shown. The Supreme Court disagreed. A CCI communication dated December 8, 2020, placed on record by Twinstar, showed that approval came before CoC voting closed on December 11. The requirement was met, but this did not save the plan.
6. The CoC can revisit its approval
The court rejected Twinstar’s main argument that the CoC became functus officio once it approved the plan. The CoC is not an adjudicatory body, it said, but a body of creditors that continues to exist until a plan is implemented or liquidation is ordered. Most of its members are public sector lenders “dealing with public money”, and it acts as a “custodian of public trust”. Citing Kalyani Transco, the court held that an approved plan does not attain finality until appeals under Sections 61 and 62 are decided.
Here, the approval “never attained finality”. It was challenged within about a month and stayed by the NCLAT, which ordered status quo ante, an order the court called “unusual”. It was after this that about 95% of the CoC sought to reconsider. The court said the CoC’s power came not only from the interim order but from “its continuing role under the Code”.
The court distinguished the precedents Twinstar cited. Ebix and Amtek Auto dealt with resolution applicants trying to walk away from approved plans. In S.M. Kamal Pasha, the CoC had tried to withdraw approval of a compliant plan only because the company’s finances had improved, which the court had called “shortsighted opportunism”. Here, the plan was found non-compliant and set aside on appeal. “The binding character of a plan approved by the CoC presupposes a plan that is compliant with the Code,” the court said.
The oil and gas assets: Dhoot’s appeals fail
The second part of the judgment concerns participating interests in four oil and gas concessions in Brazil and the Nunukan block in Indonesia. VIL does not hold them directly. They sit in a chain of subsidiaries: VIL owns all of VOVL, which holds 99% of Videocon Hydrocarbon Holdings Ltd (VHHL) in the Cayman Islands, with VIL holding the remaining 1%. VHHL owns Videocon Energy Brasil Ltd (VEBL), which held half of the Brazilian joint venture IBV, and Videocon Indonesia Nunukan Inc (VINI). The other half of IBV was held by BPRL, a Bharat Petroleum Corporation (BPCL) arm.
In February 2020, the NCLT accepted Dhoot’s plea that VIL and its subsidiaries were a “single economic unit” and ordered the assets included in VIL’s insolvency. The NCLAT stayed that order within a week, and set it aside on May 14, 2026. It held that the NCLT had “mixed up” consolidation with inclusion of assets, and that Dhoot had taken contradictory stands. Dhoot argued in the Supreme Court that VIL was the original acquirer and the subsidiaries were mere special purpose vehicles.
Subsidiary assets are excluded by law
The court held that a holding company and its subsidiary, even a wholly owned one, are distinct legal persons. The holding company does not own the subsidiary’s assets. It relied on Vodafone International Holdings and on the IBC itself. Explanation (b) to Section 18 excludes the assets of “any Indian or foreign subsidiary” from what the resolution professional takes control of, and Section 36(4)(d) excludes them from the liquidation estate.
Tracing how the assets were acquired, beginning with VIL’s 2005 MoU with BPCL, the court found that “VIL does not hold any interest directly in the Brazilian and Indonesian assets but through its subsidiaries”.
Dhoot estopped by his own conduct
The court held Dhoot could not “approbate and reprobate”. It listed eight reasons:
- In November 2016, VIL asked lenders to release it as co-obligor on the loans.
- In January 2017, Dhoot himself asked SBI to shift facilities from VIL and VOVL to VOVL alone.
- He took part in the lenders’ valuation and monetisation of the assets.
- His own Section 12A proposal kept the offshore assets out.
- He never sought to vacate the NCLAT’s February 2020 stay.
- He neither objected to the plan nor challenged the rejection of his proposal.
- His application to bring VOVL into the consolidated process was dismissed for non-prosecution in February 2022, and that order is final.
- His own consolidation application made no prayer to include foreign subsidiaries.
No route through agreements or veil-lifting
Dhoot relied on three Beneficial Ownership Agreements under which the overseas subsidiaries agreed to hold the assets for VIL’s benefit. The court said these intra-group arrangements do not transfer assets to the holding company.
He also cited admissions by SBI in lender meetings between 2012 and 2017 and in a 2018 consolidation application. The court said correspondence “cannot confer title” on a holding company without a document showing transfer, and “cannot alter the legal position”.
The court distinguished Alpha Corp, where the companies shared directors with the parent and had no assets other than land leased for the project. Substance-over-form reasoning cannot override a statutory exclusion, it said. On LIC v. Escorts, it noted that the corporate veil is lifted to prevent fraud or evasion of a statute, “whereas here the statute itself… excludes the assets of a subsidiary”.
Haircut, Section 12A and fraud claims
The court dismissed Dhoot’s challenge to the haircut and liquidation value as matters of the CoC’s “non-justiciable” commercial wisdom. The valuation was the average of two registered valuers and he never challenged it.
On his Section 12A proposal, the court noted Dhoot was not even an “applicant” under that section. The CoC nonetheless had it evaluated, heard a presentation and put it to vote. Its rejection was a business decision.
The allegations of fraud and collusion against SBI, the resolution professional and the CoC were “general and bereft of the particulars required in law”. The court said the March 2018 invocation of the pledge over VOVL’s shares was enforcement of security by VOVL’s lenders. Any challenge to that pre-insolvency transaction must be made before the NCLT under the IBC.
BPRL’s purchase of the Brazil stake stands
In VOVL’s separate insolvency, BPRL exercised its right of first refusal under the 2008 quotaholders’ agreement and matched offers from PRIO S.A. and Eneva S.A. for VEBL’s stake in IBV. VOVL’s CoC approved the sale with 99.96% of the vote and the NCLT cleared it in June 2024.
The court upheld the sale. The transaction did not treat subsidiaries’ assets as VOVL’s, it said, and Dhoot’s challenge rested entirely on the premise that the assets belonged to VIL, which had been rejected. Dhoot had no locus. The deal had concluded on July 2, 2026, and BPRL had funded VEBL’s defaults for years to preserve the assets.
Vendors get liberty to pursue avoidance claims
The VIL Vendors Association’s appeal was dismissed. The court said its grievance was “derivative”: since the oil and gas assets are not part of VIL’s estate, excluding them causes operational creditors no legal injury. Whether assets belong in the insolvency is a question of law under Section 18, not commercial wisdom.
The court pointed to another route. If VIL parted with its rights or gave a guarantee without consideration, the remedy lies under Sections 43 to 51 and 66 of the IBC, which deal with preferential, undervalued, extortionate and fraudulent transactions. No such application has been filed. “Having regard to the nature of the issue”, the court gave the association liberty to pursue available remedies.
Cross-border question left open
The judgment decides the overseas assets question purely on domestic law and does not address cross-border insolvency. Indonesia’s Pertamina argued that VINI, a Cayman Islands company, is outside the IBC, and that assets abroad can be reached “only through Sections 234 and 235 of the Code”, which were never invoked. These sections provide for reciprocal arrangements with foreign countries and letters of request to foreign courts. The bench did not engage with the argument, ruling instead under Section 18.
India has notified no reciprocal arrangement under Section 234 and has not adopted the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency, which the Insolvency Law Committee recommended in 2018. How an Indian resolution process can reach assets held abroad therefore remains unsettled.
Much of the value had moved on in any case. Pertamina told the court that VINI’s 23% Nunukan interest was deemed transferred to it and a BPRL affiliate in July 2019 after VINI defaulted, and that Indonesia formally effected the transfer in July 2026. BPRL said it invested about $1,092 million in the Brazilian assets after Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs approval in July 2022, and paid about $151 million between December 2018 and December 2025 to cure VEBL’s defaults.
Guardrails on NCLAT remands
Before closing, the bench set conditions on when the NCLAT may send an approved plan back to the CoC. This section is likely to be cited well beyond the Videocon case.
The court described remand as “the connecting link” between the CoC, the NCLT and the NCLAT. It lets the appellate tribunal check legality “without trespassing on the commerciality”. Without remand, the NCLAT faces a binary choice: affirm a non-compliant plan, or set it aside and, once the insolvency period has run out, push the company towards liquidation.
But the court said remand has costs: prolonged litigation, erosion of certainty, financial burden and depletion of asset value. It cited a September 2025 TrustBridge working paper on the misuse of remand orders by appellate tribunals. It set five conditions:
- Remand must further the IBC’s objectives of keeping the company a going concern, fair recovery for all creditors and maximising asset value. It is “not justified merely because the power to order it exists”.
- It must rest on a finding of legal non-compliance under Section 30(2), or under another law within the meaning of Section 61(3)(i).
- It must be used “sparingly and with circumspection”, and not in a way that departs from procedure the IBC expressly prescribes.
- It can be corrective: where the NCLT modifies a curable plan itself instead of sending it to the CoC, the NCLAT may remand to restore the division of roles.
- Every remand order must carry a strict direction to follow the IBC’s timelines, “so that the remedy does not itself become a source of the very delay that the Code seeks to avoid”.
Other directions
GAIL (India) Ltd had sought to intervene, arguing that approval of the plan would extinguish its claim. Since the NCLAT’s order has been upheld, the court said the resolution professional will deal with GAIL’s claim under the IBC. The NCLAT will decide GAIL’s pending appeal (No. 908 of 2025) in light of this judgment, and all of GAIL’s contentions are left open.
The Centre also sought to intervene, arguing that VIL’s interest in oil and gas blocks under production sharing contracts is only a right of exploration and extraction. The court said that question will arise when a plan dealing with those interests is considered, and the Centre is free to raise it before the resolution professional and the NCLT.
Also See: Firestar Diamond liquidator to auction ED-released diamonds, jewellery on Dec 21
Discover more from Insolvency Tracker
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.